When it comes to selecting the perfect roofing material for your home, the decision often boils down to two key factors—how much it’s going to cost and how well it performs over time. For homeowners in the market for a new roof, two popular contenders often come up in conversation—synthetic cedar shake roofing and traditional asphalt shingles.
Both of these materials offer distinct benefits, but they differ substantially in areas such as:
- Cost
- Durability
- Maintenance
- Environmental impact
This blog post will give you everything you need to know about synthetic cedar shake roofing cost vs asphalt shingles, helping you make an informed decision for your home.
What Are Synthetic Cedar Shake Roofs and Asphalt Shingles?
Before we compare the costs, it’s important to briefly understand what each roofing option is and what makes it unique.
Synthetic Cedar Shake Roofing
Synthetic cedar shake replicates the rustic charm and beauty of natural cedar wood while being made from modern composite materials like recycled rubber or plastic polymers. It’s designed to offer the aesthetic appeal of cedar wood without the downsides of rot, pests, and maintenance that often come with natural wood.
Asphalt Shingles
On the other hand, asphalt shingles are one of the most commonly used roofing materials in America. Known for their affordability and ease of installation, these shingles are typically made of a fiberglass base coated with asphalt and mineral granules. They come in various styles and colors, making them a versatile option for many homeowners.
Now, let’s dig deeper into the factors that will influence your decision.
Understanding Upfront Costs
One of the most significant differences between synthetic cedar shake roofing and asphalt shingles is the upfront cost.
Synthetic Cedar Shake Roofing Cost
Synthetic cedar shake roofing typically costs between $8 and $15 per square foot, including materials and installation fees. For an average-sized home that requires about 2,000 square feet of roofing, that means you’re looking at an investment of $16,000 to $30,000.
While this may seem pricey compared to other options, the long-term value of synthetic cedar shakes often justifies the initial cost. Their superior durability and lower maintenance requirements can reduce expenses down the road.
Asphalt Shingles Cost
By comparison, asphalt shingles are significantly more budget-friendly. They generally range from $2.50 to $5.50 per square foot, with total costs for installation typically falling between $5,000 and $11,000 for an average-sized roof.
For homeowners on a tighter budget, asphalt shingles offer an affordable, straightforward option. However, long-term durability issues may offset the lower upfront cost.
Comparing Longevity and Durability
Your roof faces constant exposure to harsh weather conditions, from heavy rain and wind to scorching sun and snow. How long your roof lasts and its ability to withstand these challenges can greatly influence its overall value.
Synthetic Cedar Shake
Synthetic cedar shakes are highly durable, with a lifespan of 40–50 years when properly installed and maintained. Their composite materials are resistant to rot, insect damage, and fire, offering superior performance compared to traditional wood shakes.
Not only are synthetic products designed to withstand harsh climates, but their color also fades much slower than natural wood, preserving that beautiful cedar look for decades.
Asphalt Shingles
By contrast, asphalt shingles typically last 20–30 years on average. While they are designed to handle standard weather conditions, they are less resistant to severe storms, hail, or extreme heat compared to synthetic roofing materials.
Over time, asphalt shingles may develop issues such as curling, cracking, or granule loss, which can require regular repairs—or even a full roof replacement.
Verdict: If you’re looking for a low-maintenance, long-lasting option, synthetic cedar shakes are a clear winner in this category.
Maintenance Requirements
The level of maintenance required for your roof can impact not only your annual expenses but also the time and energy you need to invest in upkeep.
Synthetic Cedar Shake
One of the standout benefits of synthetic cedar shake roofing is its minimal maintenance requirements. Synthetic materials don’t suffer from common issues like mold, mildew, or pest infestations. Plus, they’re typically manufactured to be fire-resistant, so you won’t have to worry about additional treatments.
Routine inspections and occasional cleaning are usually all that’s needed to keep synthetic cedar shakes in great condition.
Asphalt Shingles
Maintaining asphalt shingles can be more demanding. Over time, these roofs may require regular inspections to spot damage, fix loose shingles, or replace worn-out sections.
While maintenance isn’t overly burdensome, it can add up in terms of cost and effort, especially if your asphalt roof experiences frequent weather-related wear and tear.
Tip: Regularly clearing debris and keeping an eye on storm-related damage can help prolong the lifespan of your asphalt shingles.
Comparing Aesthetic Appeal
Your roof plays a significant role in defining the curb appeal of your home. For many homeowners, this can be just as important as cost or maintenance.
Synthetic Cedar Shake
Synthetic cedar shakes are prized for their natural beauty and high-end look. They provide the rich, textured appearance of real cedar wood, adding a timeless charm to any home. Plus, they come in a variety of colors and styles, so you can choose what best complements your home’s design.
Asphalt Shingles
While asphalt shingles are available in a wide array of colors and finishes, they generally lack the premium, sophisticated look of synthetic cedar shakes. However, for many homeowners, their simplicity and versatility are more than enough to boost curb appeal.
Verdict: If aesthetics are a top priority for you, synthetic cedar shakes deliver a more upscale, elegant look.
Different Environmental Impacts
If sustainability is a key consideration for you, this comparison will help you determine which option aligns better with your environmental values.
Synthetic Cedar Shake
Synthetic cedar shakes are often made from recycled or recyclable materials, which makes them an environmentally friendly choice. Their longer lifespan also means reduced waste compared to materials that require more frequent replacements, such as asphalt shingles.
Additionally, since they don’t require chemical treatments like real cedar shakes, synthetic options have less environmental impact during production.
Asphalt Shingles
While asphalt shingles are widely accessible, they have a higher environmental footprint. Most shingles are made from non-renewable petroleum-based materials, and they can contribute to significant landfill waste during roof replacements.
Some manufacturers now offer recyclable asphalt shingles, but availability may vary depending on your location.
Verdict: Synthetic cedar shake roofing is the greener choice, especially if you’re passionate about sustainable living.
The Bottom Line
Ultimately, the decision between synthetic cedar shake roofing and asphalt shingles will depend on your priorities—whether it’s budget, longevity, maintenance, aesthetics, or environmental impact.
Choose Synthetic Cedar Shake Roofing If…
- You prioritize long-term durability and low maintenance.
- You love the elegant look of cedar wood.
- You value eco-friendly materials and sustainability.
- You’re willing to invest in a premium roofing solution.
Choose Asphalt Shingles If…
- You’re working with a limited budget.
- Your roofing needs are more basic.
- You’re looking for a quick, cost-effective solution.
- Longevity and high-end aesthetics aren’t as important.
Both options have their strengths, so it’s worth considering what matters most for your home.
Need Help Deciding? Talk to Springfield Roofing
At Springfield Roofing, we know your roof is one of the most important investments you’ll make for your home. Whether you’re leaning toward synthetic cedar shake or asphalt shingles, our team of experienced professionals can provide expert guidance to match the right roofing material with your needs and budget.
We offer:
- Free consultations to explore all available options.
- Expert installation services designed for lasting results.
- Premium materials that align with your budget and style.
Get in touch with us today to discuss your next roofing project.
Your perfect roof is only a call away.
