Metal Roof vs Shingles Cost: What Are The 7 Factors?

When comparing roofing options, many homeowners are struck by the differences in metal roof vs shingles cost. While shingles are often the default choice for residential roofs, metal roofing continues to gain popularity for its durability, aesthetics, and long-term value.

In this guide, we break down:

• What impacts the cost of both metal and shingle roofs
• Installation factors you might not have considered
• Which roofing type makes the most sense for your long-term goals

💵 Initial Cost Comparison

The upfront investment can vary dramatically between these two roofing materials.

Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles are generally the most budget-friendly option on the market. They’re quick to produce, easy to install, and available in a wide range of styles and colors. On average, installation costs fall between $3.50 and $5.50 per square foot.

This makes shingles ideal for homeowners working within a tighter budget or looking for a quicker turnaround time.

Metal Roofing

Metal roofs can range from $7 to $14 per square foot, depending on the type of metal (steel, aluminum, copper, etc.). The price tag includes higher material costs and the need for specialized installation techniques.

Although more expensive upfront, metal roofs may offer longer-term value and better performance in harsh climates.

✅ 7 Key Factors That Affect the Total Cost

The real cost of your roof goes far beyond materials. Here are the most important cost influencers:

1. Material grade and type: Not all shingles or metals are created equal. Architectural shingles cost more than basic 3-tab versions, while copper roofing is significantly more expensive than steel or aluminum.
2. Roof complexity: Steep pitches, multiple gables, valleys, or penetrations (like skylights and chimneys) can raise labor time and costs for both materials.
3. Underlayment and insulation: Metal roofs often require specialized underlayment for moisture and thermal control. Shingle roofs may use simpler felt or synthetic options.
4. Local climate: In areas with high wind, snow, or heavy rain, building codes and material requirements can add to the installation cost.
5. Labor availability: Highly skilled metal roof installers may charge more due to the training and time involved. Shingles are more common, so labor is usually easier to source and less expensive.
6. Waste and transportation: Metal panels are heavy and may require special equipment or longer delivery times. Asphalt shingles are easier to transport and store on-site.
7. Warranty coverage: Some premium roofing systems include extended warranties that factor into the total project cost but offer peace of mind for decades.

🛠️ Longevity and Maintenance Requirements

Long-term costs include not only repairs but also potential replacements.

• Shingle Roofs: Asphalt shingles typically last 15 to 30 years, depending on weather conditions, product quality, and maintenance. They’re prone to curling, cracking, and granule loss, especially under Florida’s sun or storm conditions.
• Metal Roofs: Most metal roofs last 40 to 70 years with minimal maintenance. They’re resistant to fire, mildew, insects, and rot. Repainting may be needed after a few decades, but structural issues are rare when installed correctly.

💡 Energy Efficiency and Utility Costs

Energy efficiency directly affects your monthly bills.

• Shingles: Standard shingles absorb more heat, especially dark-colored ones. This can increase indoor temperatures and lead to higher cooling costs during warm seasons.
• Metal: Metal roofing reflects solar heat, keeping your attic and living spaces cooler. Some systems also qualify for energy efficiency tax credits or rebates. This can offset part of the higher initial investment over time.

✨ Aesthetic and Property Value Impact

Curb appeal matters when it comes to resale value.

• Shingles: Shingles are versatile and can mimic high-end looks like slate or wood shakes. However, they don’t always carry the “luxury” factor of metal when viewed by potential buyers.
• Metal: Metal roofs often give homes a sleek, contemporary, or even upscale look. In many markets, they help homes stand out and may even boost appraisal value, particularly in hurricane-prone areas where durability is a major selling point.

🌲 Environmental Impact and Sustainability

Homeowners are increasingly considering environmental factors.

• Shingle Roofing: Shingles are petroleum-based and contribute to landfill waste when removed. While recycling programs are growing, most used shingles still end up in landfills.
• Metal Roofing: Most metal roofing materials are made with recycled content and are fully recyclable at the end of their lifespan. Their longevity also reduces the environmental impact of re-roofing every 20 years.

⏰ Installation Timeline and Disruption

Installation time can affect labor costs and homeowner convenience.

• Shingles: Asphalt shingles can be installed quickly—typically within a few days. Weather permitting, the entire process is usually less disruptive for residents.
• Metal: Metal roofs take longer to install due to panel cutting, fitting, and fastening techniques. Installers must follow precise measurements and account for thermal expansion.

🤔 Final Decision: Which Roof Is Right for You?

Every home is different. When weighing metal roof vs shingles cost, it’s important to consider both your short-term budget and long-term goals.

Choose Shingles If:

• You’re on a budget: Shingles provide a dependable, cost-effective solution for standard roofing needs.
• You plan to move soon: If you’ll be selling within 5–10 years, the return on a more expensive roof may not be realized.
• You want faster installation: Projects with tight deadlines or weather constraints benefit from shingle speed.

Choose Metal If:

• You want long-term savings: Lower maintenance, better durability, and energy efficiency all add up over time.
• You live in a harsh climate: Homes in Florida or coastal regions benefit from wind and corrosion resistance.
• You’re staying long-term: A metal roof could be the last one you ever install on your home.

💪 Trust Springfield Roofing & Sheet Metal Inc. for Expert Advice

Choosing between shingles and metal can feel overwhelming, but you don’t have to decide alone. At Springfield Roofing & Sheet Metal Inc., we help homeowners weigh all factors—from material performance to labor needs—to determine the best roof for their situation.

• Experienced installers: Our crews specialize in both metal and asphalt installations.
• Upfront pricing: We walk you through every cost component before work begins.
• High-quality products: We work with trusted manufacturers to ensure long-lasting results.
• Florida-tested systems: Our recommendations reflect the challenges of local weather and building codes.

⭐️ Ready to Get Started?

Let us help you compare options and plan your roof upgrade with total confidence. Contact Springfield Roofing & Sheet Metal Inc. today to get an honest, expert breakdown of what will work best for your home and budget.